Filed by The Dude on Monday, May 18, 2026 — a satirical filed report from the newsdesk. [Parody]
WOMAN, 29, JAILED AFTER SWITCHING HER BOYFRIEND'S COSTCO KIRKLAND PROTEIN BARS WITH OFF-BRAND FIBER BARS FOR 5 MONTHS BECAUSE HE "GOT TOO COCKY ABOUT HIS PHYSIQUE"
WOMAN, 29, JAILED AFTER SWITCHING HER BOYFRIEND'S COSTCO KIRKLAND PROTEIN BARS WITH OFF-BRAND FIBER BARS FOR 5 MONTHS BECAUSE HE "GOT TOO COCKY ABOUT HIS PHYSIQUE" A Sunset City woman was allegedly jailed Tuesday after secretly replacing her boyfriend's Costco Kirkland Signature protein bars with off-brand fiber bars for nearly 5 months following a comment he made about his "summer-ready abs." Sienna Caldwell, 29, allegedly began the swap in late December after her boyfriend Tanner, 31, told her over Christmas dinner with her family that he "didn't really need to work that hard to look this good." Sienna reportedly drove to a different Costco the next morning. "Sienna didn't say anything at dinner," her sister Brooke said. "She just smiled. She passed the gravy. We should have known." Over the next 5 months, Sienna allegedly purchased 11 boxes of an off-brand fiber bar with similar packaging from a discount grocery store, carefully unwrapped each one, and reinserted them into the original Kirkland protein bar wrappers she had saved from previous boxes. The fiber bars reportedly contained 9 grams of fiber per serving. Tanner allegedly ate 2 to 3 per day. According to the police report, Tanner began experiencing what he described as "unexpected gym performance issues" by week 6, including a 14-pound drop in his deadlift PR and what his trainer called "concerning new bathroom timing." "Tanner kept telling me he was peaking," his trainer Marcus said. "I told him we should run blood work. He told me he didn't need bloodwork. He needed creatine." Sienna allegedly maintained the swap by carefully resealing the wrappers with a glue stick she kept in a drawer labeled "crafts." The scheme reportedly unraveled Monday when Tanner's mother visited and unwrapped a fresh bar to share with him, immediately noticing the texture, color, and unfamiliar branding inside. She allegedly called Sienna out at the kitchen counter. Sienna reportedly admitted everything in under 14 seconds, including the name of the discount grocery store and the location of the glue stick. She faces charges of fraud and tampering with consumer products. #funny #comedy #satire
More From The Newsdesk
BREAKINGWAITRESS ARRESTED AFTER ALLEGEDLY DUMPING A WHOLE FRYER BASKET OF…
PROVIDENCE, RI — Authorities arrested Marconi's Italian Grill waitress Sophia Renata Vitaliano, 27, on Friday…
FLORIDAFLORIDA MAN ARRESTED AFTER STEALING POLICE CRUISER FROM WAFFLE HOUSE…
PENSACOLA, FL — A Florida man was arrested after police say he stole a patrol car from a Waffle House parking…
FLORIDAFLORIDA MAN ARRESTED AFTER ALLEGEDLY TRYING TO TRADE A LIVE IGUANA…
KISSIMMEE, FL — Authorities arrested Dale Beauford Patterson, 51, on Tuesday afternoon after he allegedly…
FILEDPANAMA CITY, FL — Jacob Tanner, 31, was detained Saturday morning…
According to the police report, Tanner sat at the counter, ordered an All-Star Special with extra hash…